[Mafia] Codename: Mafia - Round 2

[TenOfSwords13]

@MadameButterflyKnife You are about to be executed. Do you have anything to say before I do so?

[MadameButterflyKnife]

i guess i've done a little wrong
and i need to be forgiven
by the liquor and the company of kings

[TenOfSwords13]

Whistle has been executed and has died.

WhistleWas GOOD

Three Evil players remain.

Day returns in two days (ish).

[TenOfSwords13]

DAY 2

PointMaid has died. PointMaid was GOOD.
NebulaChimera2211 has died. NebulaChimera2211 was GOOD.

8 Players live.

Day Ends in 5 Days (17th) at 8PM BST / 3PM EDT

[SmilyCube112]

Well, Day 2 and I promised I'd talk more on my role this day. Where should I start?

[LavenderDream]

Ok, I need to hear from 


[*]Florien
[*]Whistle
[*]TheOtherCG


I detected 0 evil players on me last night, so if you're one of the above three, explain.

[LavenderDream]

 nvm whistle's dead

[MadameButterflyKnife]

oh, i can assure you.

Florien is evil.

let me explain. my true role is not that of a bulletproof fiend. i am the Modern Cain, burdened to present evil to find redemption in such things. if i make an honest, good attempt at convincing you im evil? i discover the identity of an evil man. and i did so. and i found the sin lying within Florien's heart.

of course, i revealed my true role now for a couple of reasons. one is i voted for Lavender, and they confirmed no evil folk. whistle took my bullet and accidentally revealed later that she takes bullets only for good folk. and of course, its because i discovered it was Florien. an ultimate theat in social deduction games.


and so.

/vote Florien

[LavenderDream]

Oh I can agree Knife
/vote Florien

[Mr. Lee Hammer]

I will say one thing, based on a pattern on who dies when Florien is scum. The more competent and active players die early on. And let's face it, Point and Nebula have both been very reliable as town players. So I can get behind that.

/Vote Florien

[SmilyCube112]

I have more to add to that, Knife.

My role allows me to do research on a topic (the name of the topic can only be a single word, no more). What I got was more akin to basically being given a hint as to whom the Scum is. Night 1's hint was: "The sum of unique letters in the names of all evil team members is odd.", and I ran with it.

I had narrowed it down to just five people who could be potential Scum, which was:
- Cutegirl920fire
- Despair's Archon of Memes
- Florien
- MadameButterflyKnife
- PointMaid

Honestly, we all know what happened during Night 2, with PointMaid's demise and Knife's

alignment verificationWe could've used a deadchat.

, no need to go do a recap. Let's just skip to dealing with Flor while CG and DAM defend themselves.

[SmilyCube112]

Oh, and before anyone says anything:

/Vote Florien

[LavenderDream]

The voting threshold is still (half the number of alive players) + one, right?

[TenOfSwords13]

Yep, the number of votes required to execute is now 5

[LavenderDream]

Ok, new plan devised, nobody vote Florien until Despair's Archon of Memes and TheOtherCG vote me, then we hammer Florien. Just as a precaution.

[Kennifer]

okay I'll hold off on voting til we hear from everyone.

[TheOtherCG]

Okay, I'm back. What am I supposed to do? I didn't do anything during the last night phase as my role isn't capable of that.

[MadameButterflyKnife]

we want you to vote for Lavender.

[TheOtherCG]

Why though?

[Florien]

Wait wait wait

I promise you, I'm innocent here. Think about it. Point scanned me, and I tracked as town. Then knife scans me and I track as scum? This doesn't follow, because obviously one of those has to be wrong, and Point's role specifically says (I think she said) it can only be wrong about town, it can't be wrong about scum.

This isn't how things work. Knife must be wrong, somehow. Though I don't think she's scum.

I think it's CG, more on gut than anything.

/Vote Cutegirl920fire

[Florien]

Oh, also "the sum of all unique letters in the scum teams names are odd" doesn't narrow it down as much as you think. It's not about individual scum team members, it's about the entire scum team put together. So you need all their names together.

[MadameButterflyKnife]

@CG you need to vote for Lavender so she can see tonight if you're scum

@Florien uh huh, i'm not buying it tbh. Point could have misinterpreted the wording of her role when Ten sent it to her, and Lavender's evidence still makes you relatively suspicious.

[MadameButterflyKnife]

oh i did NOT realize thats how pings work. sorry about that ping

[Florien]

No, I don't think Point misinterpreted anything. She sent a DM to me because she knew I was town, and relayed that it definitely and clearly said it could never be wrong about scum, only town, when I pressed on the matter to make sure I understood exactly how the role worked.

So if she was wrong, Lavender's results could also be wrong somehow. If she's right, your results are wrong, and that also means Lavender's results are wrong.

I don't know what's making results wrong though.

[MadameButterflyKnife]

and how am i to trust you that Point said that? she's dead, remember? you could lie about any supposed DMs that happened between you and her to hide the fact that it's two pieces of evidence against you.