[Fin] Murder in the Mountains (End)

[TenOfSwords13]

The Soul certainly must say something. I am not content with being the only being who trusts them.

[Kennifer]

"Understandable, since that throws suspicion on you as well."

[Magolor]

"...I think our only option is to vote someone out. The Cultists would obviously only kill people that are confirmed innocent and have useful investigative abilities, like last night. We know the Cultists are among those four...

Red and the Soul vouch for each other. That means if one is innocent, so is the other. That also means nobody but the Soul could be working with Red here, if they're the Cultists.

Blue could be a Rolecop, or just an extremely lucky Dualgunner, if Red became an Investigator.
Nellie, however, could be either role equally likely, if she is the last Cultist.

So I think we should try and deduce what the last non-Wannabe Cultist's role is."

[wingedcatgirl]

> are the bone chippings from a couple of days ago still there, and if they are, then are there any new bone chippings?

The closet definitely still contains bone chips. Hard to say whether any are new.

[PointMaid]

Well, we haven't had any double murders that a dualgunner might have done. They could be saving it, but that seems unlikely, doesn't it? Or they could technically have done a murder when the main attack was repelled. They could be a vanillaizer, but nobody has reported not being able to use their roles permanently. (...Although they could have targeted someone it had no effect on.) The most likely seems to be the rolecop. They did find out and attack some of the more important helpers. Although... we've been sharing our roles anyway, so that's not exactly a huge thing.

[Caret]

Nellie suddenly glares at Lotus. "I'm a boy, not a girl! Is Nellie a girl name? Did I seriously not thought of that while coming up with that alias? ... Disregard what I just said."

[Caret]

"Ahem... Anyways, I also think that our cultist is a Rolecop, since a Dualgunner would have probably fired their shot by now, considering that everyone roleclaimed so early, and a Vanillaizer would have also used their power by now to take down Kondraki or Lotus or somebody."

[Kennifer]

Amy ponders a moment, remembering something.

"Mitsuha was the Vanillizer, wasn't she? I could've sworn one of the voices said that after her execution."

[Caret]

She was? Oh, then let me update my documents...

The Grand List Of Night Actions

Amnesiac (Red, also a Rickroller) - claims to have remembered being the Investigator on Night 3

Bulletproof (Z, confirmed through physical evidence and Knuckles) - got targeted by the cultists on Night 3 through Kondraki's swapping

Bus Driver (Kondraki, confirmed through multiple people's accounts lining up with each other, also a Rickroller):

• Night 1: Swapped Red and Malakhiri, got rickrolled
  
• Night 2: Swapped Chip & Ada and Amy
  
• Night 3: Swapped Z and Lotus
  
• Night 4: Swapped Kondraki and Amy, got rickrolled
  
• Night 5: Swapped Amy and Red, got rickrolled
  

CPR Doctor (Soul) - allegedly saved Red on Night 4

Commuter (Nellie) - commuted on Night 4, one commute remains

Coroner (Blue):

• Night 1: N/A
  
• Night 2: Visited Freddy, who turned out to be the Investigator
  
• Night 3: Visited Lloyd, who turned out to be the Jailer
  
• Nights 4 and 5: ???, possibly did nothing since Malakhiri's death has rendered the Coroner's power as redundant
  

Fruit Vendors (Chip & Ada, confirmed through "Mod Error"? idk):

• Night 1: Tried to send fruit to Amy, but was instead jailed
  
• Night 2: Sent fruit to Lotus
  
• Night 3: Tried to send sour grapes to Kondraki, but was instead sent to Malakhiri as a "Mod Error"
  
• Nights 4 and 5: Did nothing
  

Investigator (Freddy, possibly confirmed by Blue/Red):

• Night 1: ???
  
• Nights 2 and 3: N/A
  
• Night 4: tried to investigate Amy and Tainted Soul for the CPR Doctor, but ended up investigating Kondraki instead of Amy and was rickrolled (Bus Driver swapped Kondraki and Amy)
  
• Night 5: investigated Tainted Soul for the CPR Doctor, got a positive result
  

Jailer (Lloyd, possibly confirmed by Blue)

• Night 1: Jailed Chip & Ada
  
• Night 2: ???
  

Stalker (Lotus, confirmed by Kondraki and Knuckles):

• Night 1: Tried to stalk Malakhiri, but instead ended up stalking Red and was rickrolled (Bus Driver swapped Malakhiri and Red)
  
• Night 2: Stalked Knuckles, who visited Malakhiri
  
• Night 3: Stalked Amy, who visited Tainted Soul
  
• Night 4. Tried to stalk Kondraki, but instead ended up stalking Amy, who visited Mitsuha (Bus Driver swapped Kondraki and Amy)
  
• Night 5. Stalked Knuckles, who visited Nellie
  

Watcher (Knuckles, confirmed):

• Night 1. Watched Kondraki, who was visited by no one
  
• Night 2. Watched Malakhiri, who was also visited by no one
  
• Night 3. Tried to watch Lotus, but ended up watching Z instead, who was visited by Kondraki and Malakhiri (Bus Driver swapped Lotus and Z)
  
• Night 4. Tried to watch Amy, but ended up watching Kondraki instead and was rickrolled
  
• Night 5. ???, but presumably watched Nellie, who was presumably visited by Amy
  

Unjester (Amy, very likely confirmed):

• Night 1. Tried to visit Malakhiki, but end up visiting Red instead and got rickrolled (Bus Driver swapped Malakhiri and Red)
  
• Night 2. Tried to visit Chip & Ada, but ended up visiting herself instead (how is that possible?) (Bus Driver swapped Chip & Ada)
  
• Night 3. Visited the Soul, nothing happened
  
• Night 4. Visited Mitsuha, nothing happened
  
• Night 5. Visited Nellie, nothing happened
  

Kills and kill attempts

• Night 1: Freddy (Investigator) was killed by dismemberment
  
• Night 2: Lloyd (Jailer) was killed by some kind of neck snap
  
• Night 3: Malakhiri attempted to kill Lotus, but Kondraki was able to redirect the attack to Z and prevent any kills that night
  
• Night 4: The cultists allegedly attempted to kill Red, but the Soul was allegedly able to save him through the Soul's role
  
• Night 5: Knuckles (Watcher) was killed by a stabbing
  

Innocents, Cultists, and the Unconfirmed

Confirmed to be innocent

• Freddy (dead, likely Investigator)
  
• Lloyd (dead, likely Jailer)
  
• Knuckles (dead, Watcher)
  
• Kondraki (Bus Driver, pretty much confirmed by Knuckles during the Night 3 fiasco. Also a Rickroller.)
  
• Lotus (Stalker, per Malakhiri's botched attempt to kill her on Night 3)
  
• Chip & Ada (Fruit Vendors, nobody else has claimed be a fruit vendor, and the "Mod Error" pretty much confirms it)
  
• Z (Bulletproof, per physical evidence and Knuckles)
  
• Amy (Unjester, I presume that the cultists communicate through magic, so why would a cultist visit one of their own if they don't want to be caught?)
  

Not confirmed to be innocent

• The Soul (claims to be the CPR Doctor, but wouldn't that be the perfect cover for inducting a Wannabe into the Death Coven?)
  
• Red (Amnesiac, claims to have remembered being the Investigator, but might have actually remembered being the Wannabe if the Soul is a cultist. Also a Rickroller.)
  
• Nellie (claims to be the Commuter, all attempts to confirm my role have seemingly been foiled by the cultists, but I got the feeling that I'm going to end up framed somehow)
  
• Blue (claims to be the Coroner, less likely to be a cultist then the other people but I'm still putting on this list just in case)
  

Cultists

• Malakhiri (Janitor, claimed to be Masons with Mitsuha)
  
• Mitsuha (Vanillaizer, claimed to be Masons with Malakhiri)
  
• Jean (Wannabe, claimed to be Bulletproof)
  
• I think that the final(?) cultist might be a Rolecop due to the fact that the Dualgunner hasn't fired their shot yet even though everyone's (supposed) roles has been made clear by now
  

[PointMaid]

...Does narrowing down the likely cult roles tell us anything helpful?

[Caret]

"Actually, I have two questions. Oh, wicked Avatar of Death! First of all, can there be more then one person with the same role besides the Rickrollers? And second of all, do the cultists know who the bear automation and Lloyd's roles are, or were they also in the dark regarding their roles?

[wingedcatgirl]

"Before the Amnesiac got involved, no two people could have the same gift - except, of course, two Masons, if there were Masons."

"As for the Janitor, they don't get to learn the roles of the dead. Thinking of upgrading that for my next game..."

"You're planning to do this again?!"

"It was so much fun this time!"

[Kennifer]

"That's… a messed up idea of fun. Otherwise good to know, though."

[Caret]

"So that would mean that the cultists were as in the dark as we were. That would also mean that Blue might indeed be the Coroner, since the Coroner's power would also be useful to the cultists, especially to a Rolecop who doesn't want to waste their shots so early in Death's twisited game. That would also narrow our list of suspects down to the Soul + Red... and me."

[TenOfSwords13]

That is certainly one way to phrase it, yes. So... the meaning of those facts is that, for myself at least, you must be the last cultist, Nellie. I am not yet ready to initiate a vote against yourself, as I am a highly suspicious individual, however I won't object to your demise.

[PointMaid]

Um... I was assuming those things you asked about were true, and wasn't especially suspicious of Blue. But how does it rule her out categorically? Am I missing something?

[TenOfSwords13]

A coroner must exist, given the janitor, so who is it? It is certainly not Freddy, nor Lloyd, so it must be Blue.

[PointMaid]

...Right, yes. I see the reasoning. There must be a coroner, and the Cultists wouldn't want to kill them because it helps them too to narrow down what roles are possible, and it doesn't have the power to directly uncover the cultists themselves.

Not completely definitive, but yes, extremely unlikely Blue is anything but the Coroner. Lloyd was certainly the Jailer, given his demonstrated effect on Chip and my ability to send fruit.

[PointMaid]

...So, yeah. The Soul (and by extension, Red), or Nellie.

Here's this for a prompt. What helpful things have either of them done that a Cultist would have no reason to do, even to maintain plausibility as innocent?

[TenOfSwords13]

Nothing comes to mind for I.

[Zanreo]

"Can't really think of anything either..."

[Kennifer]

Amy just shakes her head. She can't remember the Soul doing much other than hiding in the closet, and the only one who could vouch for them was.. someone also potentially suspicious.

[PointMaid]

...If we're not able to narrow down anything more definitively soon, I think I'm going to have to advocate voting for the Soul. I still think they're the most suspicious, they have physical evidence against them with the bone chips, and they won't come explain themself. If they're innocent... we can believe Red, and Nellie is almost certainly the last Cultist. And if they're not but there's one more cultist -- well, it's pretty clear who that would have to be, isn't it?

[Zanreo]

"Gonna have to agree with that, yeah... I'm sorry, but..."

/vote Soul

[Kennifer]

"I'm really sorry in advance if you're really the CPR Doctor..."

Amy looks like she really doesn't want to do this, but... well, as seen with Mitsuha the day prior, meekness and innocence can be deceiving...

/vote Soul