[Mafia] Codename: MAFIA - Round1 Over, Good Wins by Trickery

[NebulaChimera2211]

At least 4 of us have been relatively quiet, and not said much to contribute. Statistically, there's a 10-20% chance that it's none of them, and hence it's likely to be one of them. Be aware.

Bus Driver seems like it can also be an evil role. So there's a chance artsyGeek is telling the truth about being a Bus Driver... because they're an evil one.

Florien: FoS only if Matthew is revealed to be good.
My immediate guess is that most of them either do, or are at least aren't wildly different to an existing role.
I raise possibilities to make sure they've been accounted for. Remember last time when Town got blindsided by a Werewolf?
I think you're right that we should vote someone off today, assuming Whistle is innocent. If she is, then the worst case scenario assuming no elimination is 5v3 MELo (her godchild is attacked, and she sacrifices herself to kill another innocent). If her godchild isn't attacked, or she for some reason doesn't save them, tomorrow is simply 6v3 PMELo instead. Either way, the threat of a D2 miselimination giving the baddies the win remains.
Assuming a miselimination, the scenarios would be 4v3 ELo or 5v3 PELo, so there doesn't seem to be a threat of imminent loss even then.

Smily: Is the PM thing just roleplaying?

Matthew: There's less than three days left, and things have slowed down lately. Now might be a good time to state them.

Whistle: You don't necessarily have to take a side in these things. For example, this Matthew vs Florien thing could be good vs good or evil vs evil. In the case of the latter, be wary if the survivor uses "I got scum eliminated" for towncred.