07-23-2022, 14:50:06 PM
Oh wow that's a lot of stuff to mentally process first thing in the morning.
Florien, as usual, is being very confusing. I'm not sure how telling it is because Florien is always confusing and has done stuff like this both when inno (like in The Murder Challenge) and scum (like in CC2). So I hope people will understand if I don't immediately put my trust in them just because this strategy worked in Witch Trip; it almost worked in CC2 on the other side if not for bus driver shenanigans. I'd say we could go along this time and see how whoever Florien leads us to ends up flipping, but if their target flips green it doesn't tell much as they've mislimmed/almost mislimmed innos before both as scum and as town, especially on the first day. If their target flips red then that's potentially more telling (though they did throw a scummate under the bus in CC2 so even that isn't certain.) But either they're trying to be helpful or they're being extremely devious especially with asking for a mass roleclaim. Either way, can't argue they're not good at the game.
Matthew also has a similar history of acting similarly whatever side he's on. He gets pretty defensive when mis-accused as inno as we know from YFF3. He also has a tendency to try to start bandwagons which is a thing I thought seemed potentially sus but, again, YFF3 shows he does this when inno too.
Whistle seems like she's got a savior/guardian angel type role which does work well with her Godmother nickname. So that much tracks, at least. (Unless she's got a Mafia Don role and is deceiving us. Godmother, Godfather... yeah.) But definitely going to give the benefit of the doubt for now even with the bandwagon jumping after the joke vote. (That and she'd had an actual reason for her vote that wasn't a meme.) Anyway I'd say she's clean.
I agree that voting a Kamikaze may be a bad idea based on the types of roles a name like that could have led to.
Nebula doesn't seem to be acting sussy aside from the meme vote but I'm not sure she expected people to jump on that. (Or it could've been a way to see who would jump on it for all I know.)
Most other people haven't posted enough to give me much information yet, even with their roleclaims. This doesn't seem to be the type of setup that uses the clearly defined roles but might have abilities similar to them; for example Matt's claim reminds me a bit of Point's in Witch Trip, might be more of a warning "hey if you have an investigation skill use it on someone else so you get an accurate result" pre-emptively? I dunno.
I'll wait to see more posts from everyone before I decide. (...though silence could also be telling, hmm.)
Florien, as usual, is being very confusing. I'm not sure how telling it is because Florien is always confusing and has done stuff like this both when inno (like in The Murder Challenge) and scum (like in CC2). So I hope people will understand if I don't immediately put my trust in them just because this strategy worked in Witch Trip; it almost worked in CC2 on the other side if not for bus driver shenanigans. I'd say we could go along this time and see how whoever Florien leads us to ends up flipping, but if their target flips green it doesn't tell much as they've mislimmed/almost mislimmed innos before both as scum and as town, especially on the first day. If their target flips red then that's potentially more telling (though they did throw a scummate under the bus in CC2 so even that isn't certain.) But either they're trying to be helpful or they're being extremely devious especially with asking for a mass roleclaim. Either way, can't argue they're not good at the game.
Matthew also has a similar history of acting similarly whatever side he's on. He gets pretty defensive when mis-accused as inno as we know from YFF3. He also has a tendency to try to start bandwagons which is a thing I thought seemed potentially sus but, again, YFF3 shows he does this when inno too.
Whistle seems like she's got a savior/guardian angel type role which does work well with her Godmother nickname. So that much tracks, at least. (Unless she's got a Mafia Don role and is deceiving us. Godmother, Godfather... yeah.) But definitely going to give the benefit of the doubt for now even with the bandwagon jumping after the joke vote. (That and she'd had an actual reason for her vote that wasn't a meme.) Anyway I'd say she's clean.
I agree that voting a Kamikaze may be a bad idea based on the types of roles a name like that could have led to.
Nebula doesn't seem to be acting sussy aside from the meme vote but I'm not sure she expected people to jump on that. (Or it could've been a way to see who would jump on it for all I know.)
Most other people haven't posted enough to give me much information yet, even with their roleclaims. This doesn't seem to be the type of setup that uses the clearly defined roles but might have abilities similar to them; for example Matt's claim reminds me a bit of Point's in Witch Trip, might be more of a warning "hey if you have an investigation skill use it on someone else so you get an accurate result" pre-emptively? I dunno.
I'll wait to see more posts from everyone before I decide. (...though silence could also be telling, hmm.)
Stupid doomed timeline...