[Mafia] Codename: MAFIA - Round1 Over, Good Wins by Trickery

[SmilyCube112]

Florien: Kennifer and I agreed name and alignment don't correlate, but name and role do; I just listed hypothetical roles based on the names, assuming scum and that role and alignment correlate. You do have a point that people's roles could be just made for this. I was basing my guesses of existing roles because otherwise there's not much to work with.
I agree that it's unlikely that one of the evil people is a third party. I was just throwing it out there.
There's a chance that Matthew's genuinely a Miller, but I think it'd come with some sort of perk(s) that he's hiding. It'd be even more suspicious to claim Miller after someone claimed to get a guilty result for him, and I'd definitely put at least a policy vote on him then. But since no-one claims a guilty result on him yet, the main issue (an investigative role reveals themselves to get an innocent eliminated) disappears, and the new problem becomes that a guilty result on him can't necessarily be trusted. Though statistically speaking, a guilty result is more likely to be scum unless the investigator is Insane or Paranoid, or there's loads of Millers.

On the subject of Millers: If anyone else wants to claim "I'm good but investigative roles think I'm evil" is part of their role, I'm giving you until this time tomorrow to speak up. You don't have to make a full claim, just let us know anyone investigating you should expect a "guilty" result.

Another thing for Whistle: You mentioned that you can PM your godchild. Can your godchild send a reply to you?

Smily: Your claim seems believable to me, but it'd be risky to trust it when the fate of the game is on the line. Does your ability trigger in other ELo scenarios (e.g. 3v2)?

Before I commit to a vote, I'd like to hear what Despair's Archon of Memes and artsyGeek have to say, if anything. I'd also like to know if Lavender and TheOtherCG have anything to add.

Neb, that's actually a good question, one I'd like to answer were it not for the fact that I can only give a vague answer at best due to the limited knowledge I have. Would that be satisfactory?