07-25-2022, 09:34:29 AM
I trust the bus driver claim.
You could justify it by saying "cunning artistic disguises of misdirection". Incidentally I do have a way to check it to some degree of probability, assuming I survive tonight. Though you are right, it does seem strange considering we have no idea if roles conform to normal roles. (I doubt all of them do)
As for Kennifer, I don't know. It's one of those feelings. I wouldn't put too much stock in it right now.
As for voting off the miller, it's a miller. It's a late claim of it, and more to the point, we have no idea if we actually have investigative roles out here. We have nothing else really to go on. If it does turn out to be a normal miller, we've not lost anyone important. If it does turn out to be that Matthew is scum, then we're better off. We aren't risking anything important with that, and it's a traditional scum claim.
Now, we can try to scumread people. But I don't really think that's worth worrying about, most people play the same all the same. Though I do find it dubious how Whistle flails around wildly trying to join in on every train. We can go for Whistle next day phase if Matthew flips green, (and if she's still alive, in case of vigilante-types out here. If we have those I would recommend going for her in case of a greenflip on Matthew. If not, we'll know there are none of your ilk.)
Worst case we lose, best case we win, really. No point in thinking far beyond that.
You could justify it by saying "cunning artistic disguises of misdirection". Incidentally I do have a way to check it to some degree of probability, assuming I survive tonight. Though you are right, it does seem strange considering we have no idea if roles conform to normal roles. (I doubt all of them do)
As for Kennifer, I don't know. It's one of those feelings. I wouldn't put too much stock in it right now.
As for voting off the miller, it's a miller. It's a late claim of it, and more to the point, we have no idea if we actually have investigative roles out here. We have nothing else really to go on. If it does turn out to be a normal miller, we've not lost anyone important. If it does turn out to be that Matthew is scum, then we're better off. We aren't risking anything important with that, and it's a traditional scum claim.
Now, we can try to scumread people. But I don't really think that's worth worrying about, most people play the same all the same. Though I do find it dubious how Whistle flails around wildly trying to join in on every train. We can go for Whistle next day phase if Matthew flips green, (and if she's still alive, in case of vigilante-types out here. If we have those I would recommend going for her in case of a greenflip on Matthew. If not, we'll know there are none of your ilk.)
Worst case we lose, best case we win, really. No point in thinking far beyond that.
I am the They who says it!