[Fin] Time For Mafia - Game Over, Scum Wins

[Kennifer]

Honestly not sure whether that's sus or just... him forgetting about the game. :P

[Subparman]

Aaaaaalright shit I forgot this existed. Going off the previous honestly I feel like Dookie is towntelling and imho he's basically clear from the D1 vote (despite switching it), but it's difficult to get reads off of anyone else, granted that only really PM and Oz have been saying anything, much less actively trying to rxn.

On the topic of sussing GCB's sheeping feels lowkey scummy to me. I haven't seen his performance in regular mafia so I don't have much to go off of in terms of meta, though. A pr claim would definitely help to narrow down the setup at least.

[artsyGeek]

Sheeping?

[GoldenCityBird]

Following other people's leads without coming up with your own, iirc.

[Kennifer]

Well as for setup, since Billy was jailkeeper that narrows it down to a couple possible ones. So either we've got a couple goons on the scum side and the rest of the town is vanilla, we've got a goon and a roleblocker on the scum side and the town has vanillas and a tracker left, or there's a role cop and a goon on the scum side and towns got vanillas and a friendly neighbor.

Narrows down the possible power roles left (if any).

[PointMaid]

@Subparman: Where was GCB sheeping? I pointed out where you were the third person to vote for Playing early, when we had very little at all to go on, which seems a bit scummy bandwagoning to me. You haven't addressed that. In fact, this time, I'm going to go as far as to

/vote Subparman

[Dookie]

What's towntelling?

[PointMaid]

I assume he meant you're doing things a townie would do and scum wouldn't?

We have until tomorrow night...

[Kennifer]

Okay let's see.

GCB voted Goose first, then changed to novote. It's hard to tell if that was sheeping or if he thought Goose was sus for immediately voting me "because vampire" or it was a jokey vote like the first few seemed to be anyway. I'd be more worried about sheeping if he'd immediately changed the novote to Playing without giving a reason. The first day was kinda confusing anyway since it was "vote for an arbitrary reason" and hard to get much of a read on people just yet.

Not sure whether the accusation of sheeping is sus or just a misread, though.

[GoldenCityBird]

Yeah, I have no clue why I voted Goose. I guess Point's reasoning made sense then. Then I guess I realised it wasn't much of a reason so I switched to a no-vote. That was probably how it went, idk what past me was thinking.

[wingedcatgirl]

Votes (4 to hammer)
Subparman - PointMaid

There are approximately 34 hours left in this day phase.

[PointMaid]

I'll clarify that that first time, I wasn't really trying to make a serious accusation against Goose, I was meaning it as more of the jokey side, since I wasn't really taking their accusation as serious ("Sus In Non-Roleplaying Mafia Because Vampire"?). Just trying to get things rolling.

Although I suppose I can see how it could have been taken that way if you weren't paying a lot of attention? I'm not... really... seeing GCB as that sus, combined with retracting it later.

[Kennifer]

Yeah, Day 1 was weird, people voting arbitrarily with very little to go on, changing votes around... which is probably why we ended up hammering a townie because there were so many misleads. Oof.

[PointMaid]

I don't want to hammer an innocent again. But I do think that letting Mafia go unchecked picking people off with very little pressure on them that they're going to get hammered or make a wrong move could be worse in the long run.

[artsyGeek]

..ah fuck, there aren't that many leads, huh

aight, then. i agree with point earlier. zorua's blatant accusation of GCB sheeping with no evidence is suspicious enough.

/vote Subparman

[Kennifer]

I am rusty enough at this that I'm not sure whether Subparman is sus, also rusty at this, or what.

Sadly it's really the only lead I've got to go on, and Point makes a good, uh... point. XD All I've managed to do is figure out a couple people I'm pretty sure are inno, which is cool but doesn't hammer a scum now does it?

But yeah I guess I shall also...

/vote Subparman

[PointMaid]

I will admit to being a bit nervous that people are following my lead and do want to know if he has anything to say in response 

[Kennifer]

That's why it took me so long to vote, I was going back and reading the thread.

Unfortunately I don't really have another lead right now.

[wingedcatgirl]

Votes (4 to hammer)
Subparman - PointMaid, Geek, Kennifer E-1

[Dookie]

You know what?

On one hand, it's not good to sus out innocents.

On the other...it might be the only lead we have left.

And while I am voting Sub...I'm sus of another person too. Point, you're posting quite a lot.

I know, it sounds like a stupid argument, but it's just something I wanted to “Point” out.

>vote Subparman

[PointMaid]

You know what?

On one hand, it's not good to sus out innocents.

On the other...it might be the only lead we have left.

And while I am voting Sub...I'm sus of another person too. Point, you're posting quite a lot.

I know, it sounds like a stupid argument, but it's just something I wanted to “Point” out.

>vote Subparman

Okay, I'll address this. One, I'm usually pretty active in things like murdergames, and I'm not in one now (except for LaB which just started), so I had some time to focus on this game. It's not like murdergames, so I may have overdone it a tad. But I was also trying to actively get some responses, since it seemed pretty quiet and we didn't have a lot to go on. I'll be honest, if it turns out Zorua/Sub isn't Mafia, I will be disappointed but not that surprised, because, yes, there wasn't a ton to go on. And if that happens and you decide I'm untrustworthy and hammer me after the last few days... I won't at all be surprised. I probably would myself.

[wingedcatgirl]

Votes (4 to hammer)
Subparman - PointMaid, Geek, Kennifer, Dookie Hammered

We don't have our notes onhand, so it'll be a bit before we do the flip

[wingedcatgirl]

Apologies for the delay.

Subparman is executed in a very dramatic and cool manner. Unfortunately...

Subparman was the Town Tracker. Night has fallen. Those with night actions, DM them to me. Day will break at 8:30 CT on 3/13 (~48 hours from this post)

[wingedcatgirl]

The sun rises. You gather in the town square, dreading the inevitable. Indeed, one of you is missing, and investigating his house quickly shows why...

Dookie, Vanilla Townie, was killed during the night. Night will fall at ~9:00 CT on 3/20 (~7 days from this post).

[wingedcatgirl]

Also, as you may have gathered on your own, it's ELo.